2018-19
- Middle School Soccer Valley Middle School Conference (V.M.S.C.) tournament runner up
- Middle School Girls’ Basketball V.M.S.C. Tournament Champion
- Middle School Boys’ Basketball V.M.S.C. Regular Season and Tournament Champion
- Middle School Tennis V.M.S.C. Regular Season and Tournament Champions
- Varsity Girls’ Soccer Delaney Athletic Conference (D.A.C.) Tournament Champion and VISAA Tournament Qualifier
2017-18
- Middle School Girls’ Cross Country First Place V.M.S.C. Season and Championship Meet
- Varsity Boys’ Soccer, D.A.C. Tournament Runner-Up
2016-17
- Varsity Football Patriot Conference Champions
- Varsity Girls’ Volleyball D.A.C. Tournament Runner-Up
- Varsity Girls’ Basketball D.A.C Regular Season and Tournament Champions
2015-16
- Varsity Girls’ Basketball D.A.C. Regular Season Champion and Tournament Runner-Up
- Middle School Boys’ Basketball V.M.S.C. Regular Season and Tournament Champions
- Varsity Girls’ Soccer D.A.C. Tournament Champions
2014-15
- Varsity Volleyball D.A.C. Regular Season Champion and Tournament Runner-Up
- Girls Soccer D.A.C. Tournament Runner-Up
- Varsity Girls’ Basketball D.A.C. Tournament Runner-Up
- Middle School Boys’ Basketball V.M.S.C. Tournament Runner-Up
- Middle School Girls’ Volleyball V.M.S.C. Tournament Runner-Up
2013-14
- Cross Country D.A.C. Championships
- Lacrosse D.A.C. Tournament Runner-Up
- Wrestling 1 State Place Winner and 1 National Prep Tournament Qualifier
- Middle School Tennis V.M.S.C. Tournament Champions
2012-13
- Cross Country: D.A.C. Regular Season Champions and 1st Place in the D.A.C. Championship Race
- Football: Patriot Football Conference Runner-Up
- Wrestling: Three State Place Winners and two National Prep Tournament Qualifiers
- Middle School Girls’ Basketball: V.M.S.C. Tournament Runner-Up
- Varsity Girls’ Soccer: D.A.C. Regular Season and Tournament Champions
- Varsity Baseball: D.A.C. Tournament Champions
- Varsity Lacrosse: D.A.C. Regular Season and Tournament Runner-Up
- Middle School Tennis: V.M.S.C. Regular Season and Tournament Runner-Up
- Upper School athletes received 56 All-Conference Honors
2011-12
- Varsity Girls’ Soccer: D.A.C. Season Co-Champions
- Middle School Soccer: V.M.S.C. Season Champions
- Middle School Boys’ Basketball: V.M.S.C. Season and Tournament Champions
- Alexis Fleming ’12: Track State Champion in 100m and 200m
- Middle School Co-Ed Tennis: V.M.S.C. Champions
- Varsity Girls’ Cross Country: D.A.C. Runner-Up
- Middle School Cross Country: V.M.S.C. Cross Country Runner-Up